HabsAddict
Registered User
Right now, this minute, Guhle is in another level to all of them. Hutson is likely to outstrip them all if he gets faster and stronger. Struble/Harris are likely long term 4th to 6th defenseman, X is a unicorn and worth extra value because of his attributes. None of those 3 are top 2.I'd agree with all that.
For NJD i'd have it Mercer>Guhle>Zegras
For MTL I think I'd have it Guhle>Zegras>Mercer (just because of the current lefty surplus, although I could more than easily move Guhle to 3, depending on how Struble, Harris, Xhekaj, Hutson, etc are viewed)
For Anaheim I'd have it Zegras>Mercer>Guhle simply because they do not need another RD and because the star power and upside is important.
Every team should just keep their player
Trading Guhle will definetly leave a hole defensively that Rein or Mailman may fill. Or not.
Guhle trade can only happen if there is a GM that values him as much as the Habs. It will be a repeat of the Subban trade in terms of value.